Druckschrift 
Death and euthanasia in Jewish law : essays and responsa / edited by Walter Jacob and Moshe Zemer
Seite
115
Einzelbild herunterladen

MOSHE ZEMER

will hasten his death. In order to establish death you must prove the absence of all three conditions(set by the Hatam Sofer : an inanimate body, no pulse and no breathing)... Since there is no definition(of brain stem death) in the Talmud , we cannot invent a new definition in our time. Only when the Sanhedrin will be established, will we have the power to determine whether brain stem death is considered death or not. Until then, he said, it is forbidden to extract his heart or any other organ as long as his heart is beating.*

R. Auerbach and another ultra-orthodox colleague , Rabbi Yosef Elyashiv published the following proclamation on 18 Menahem Av, 5751(29 July, 1991):

Behold, any time that the donors heart is beating, even in the case that his entire brain, including the brain stem, is not functioning at all, which is calledbrain death, our judgement is that there is no keiter(no permission) whatsoever to remove any of his organs; doing so is a form of murder."

(Rabbi) Shlomo Zalman Auerbach (Rabbi ) Yosef Elyashiv

Auerbach strictly forbids disconnecting a brain death patient from life supporting systems:

In our day if a patient is still connected to the artificial respirator which doesnt allow him to die, his halakhic position is that part of him is alive since his heart is beating, even though this is only because of the

n2s

respirator...

Eliezer Yehudah Waldenberg, a member of the Ber Hadin

115