Druckschrift 
Only in America : the open society and Jewish law / edited by Walter Jacob in association with Moshe Zemer
Seite
35
Einzelbild herunterladen

(Vv ww Nn

MD DD Lio OK(OOX ih(P UK WV IL

Autonomy, Halakhah , and Mitzvah 35

Season are descriptive of important opportunities, not mandatory actions. They provide guidance and not governance. The fact that they utilize a quasir halakhic form is significant because it seeks to link Reform Judaism with Rabbinic Judaism and at the same time reflect the view of the Pittsburgh Platform, which maintain only such ceremonies as elevate and sanctify our lives.

The responsa, which in answering specific questions either addressed individual authority or more often to the Responsa committee, are more about a way of reasoning and decision-making that uses Jewish texts as a way of bringing guidance to an issue rather than an attempt to definitely decide the question. For us, halakhah is a way of thinking, not a set of decisions. Responsa seem increasingly to be about mitzvot bein adam le haveiro, specifically about the great ethical dilemmas we encounter in contemporary society and the boundary issues between Jews and non-Jews in an open society

Both forms of Reforms halakhic literature seek to reinforce that concept: We must never forget, though that was first and foremost how Jews related to 4000 years of Jewish history and related to 13 million Jews the world over. The burden of proof, therefore, must always be on those who want to abandon a particular tradition, not on those who want to retain it.(Rabbi Simeon Maslin, Gates of the Seasons , p. viii).

A single example from Gates of the Seasons should suffice to indicate the flavor of the character of mitzvah as portrayed in the guidebooks to practice.

In the section on Shabbat the second mitzvah listed is the mitzvah of joy(oneg). The description of this mitzvah is as follows: